Alternatives européennes à reCAPTCHA

European alternatives to Google reCAPTCHA include ALTCHA (Germany, freemium, open source) with bot checks without image puzzles; Friendly Captcha (Germany, freemium), bot protection without manual puzzles; Trustcaptcha (Germany, paid), also without image puzzles; and Swetrix CAPTCHA (Ukraine, freemium, open source), which runs its calculations in the background. The list below shows every alternative on euroboxx with its country, pricing model and open-source status.

reCAPTCHA – Google’s Bot Protection for Websites and Apps

reCAPTCHA checks whether a visitor is a person or an automated program (a bot) and protects forms, logins, and accounts against spam and abuse. It began as a research project at Carnegie Mellon University, was acquired by Google in 2009, and has since moved from distorted words to an invisible risk score. Since April 2026, Google has acted as a data processor for reCAPTCHA customers, which changes some of the older assumptions about the service.

En bref

  • Category: CAPTCHA, bot and fraud protection for websites and apps; today part of Google Cloud Fraud Defense
  • Provider: Google (Alphabet Inc.); originally a research project at Carnegie Mellon University in Pittsburgh
  • Origine : États-Unis
  • Launched: research paper in Science in 2008; acquired by Google on September 16, 2009
  • Usage: millions of sites, according to Google (no exact figure published)
  • Pricing: Essentials free up to 10,000 assessments per month; Premium USD 8 flat for 10,001 to 100,000 assessments, then USD 1 per 1,000; Enterprise with a fixed monthly commitment at USD 1 per 1,000 (Google, 2026)
  • Versions: text CAPTCHA (2008), “No CAPTCHA reCAPTCHA” checkbox (2014), invisible score-based v3 (2018)
  • Data protection role: Google processes reCAPTCHA data as a data processor since April 2, 2026

Une brève histoire qu'il est bon de connaître

reCAPTCHA was invented with a second purpose in mind. In 2008, Luis von Ahn and his colleagues at Carnegie Mellon University published their idea in the journal Science: people solving CAPTCHAs would type words from scanned books and newspaper archives that text recognition (OCR) software could not read, and so help digitise them. Among other material, the project transcribed articles from the New York Times archive. Its accuracy was 99.1%, compared with 83.5% for standard OCR. At that time, reCAPTCHA ran on more than 40,000 websites and had transcribed over 440 million words (Science, 2008).

Google acquired reCAPTCHA in September 2009. In December 2014, the “No CAPTCHA reCAPTCHA” checkbox arrived, the familiar “I’m not a robot” box. In October 2018, reCAPTCHA v3 removed the need for user interaction: instead of a puzzle, the website receives a score and chooses the most appropriate action itself.

What reCAPTCHA Does

reCAPTCHA assesses interactions on a website or in an app and returns a risk score from 0.0 to 1.0, together with reason codes. The website decides how to react. Beyond spam in forms, reCAPTCHA targets credential stuffing (automated login attempts with stolen passwords), account takeover, and the automated creation of fake accounts.

Today reCAPTCHA is part of Google Cloud Fraud Defense and comes in three usage-based tiers: Essentials, Premium, and Enterprise. Customers use it through a Google Cloud project. New “classic keys” can no longer be created, and existing ones are to be migrated.

Caractéristiques principales

  • Protection against spam and abuse in forms
  • Detection of credential stuffing, account takeover, and automated account creation
  • Risk score from 0.0 to 1.0 with reason codes
  • Invisible checks without user interaction (score-based, since v3)
  • “I’m not a robot” checkbox (v2)
  • SDKs for mobile apps
  • Password defense and multi-factor authentication (MFA)
  • Enterprise tier: a model that can be trained on your own website
  • The badge can be hidden if the site shows the notice “This site is protected by reCAPTCHA.”

Faits marquants et particularités

The role change in 2026 is the most important recent development. Since April 2, 2026, customers are the sole data controller of their reCAPTCHA data, and Google processes it under the Google Cloud Terms and the Cloud Data Processing Addendum. According to Google, references to Google’s privacy policy and terms are being removed from the badge, while the _grecaptcha cookie stays unchanged. Many articles about reCAPTCHA and data protection were written before this change.

The early figures show how quickly the project spread: after one year in operation, people had solved more than 1.2 billion CAPTCHAs (Science, 2008). This figure is historical and says nothing about today’s usage.

Points forts

  • Free entry up to 10,000 assessments per month
  • Invisible option without puzzles for users
  • Risk score with reason codes, so the website decides how to respond
  • Protection beyond forms, including account takeover and credential stuffing
  • Mobile SDKs for apps
  • Premium and Enterprise tiers with published list prices
  • Long market presence of more than a decade, according to Google
  • Since 2026, processing as a data processor under a Google Cloud contract

Limites et points critiques

Before the 2026 role change, European authorities and courts took a strict view of reCAPTCHA. In March 2023, the French CNIL fined the company Cityscoot, partly because it used reCAPTCHA for account creation, login, and password reset without informing users or asking for their consent. The CNIL did not accept the exception for pure security purposes because, in its view, Google also used the mechanism for analyses. This point accounted for EUR 25,000 of the total fine of EUR 125,000, which also covered other GDPR violations.

In September 2024, the Austrian Federal Administrative Court dismissed a complaint by website operators against a decision of the data protection authority. It found that the _GRECAPTCHA cookie contains a unique identifier and is personal data, and that reCAPTCHA is not technically necessary to run the website, so legitimate interest did not apply. The operators in that individual case needed users’ consent.

The 2026 role change does not automatically settle whether consent is still required: both decisions were based on cookie rules for access to the user’s device, while the change concerns Google’s contractual role. For transfers to the US, the EU-U.S. Data Privacy Framework (DPF) has applied since July 2023, and Google LLC states that it is certified. In September 2025, the EU General Court dismissed an action against the framework; an appeal before the EU Court of Justice is pending.

Who Is reCAPTCHA Suitable For?

reCAPTCHA works well for websites and apps with forms, logins, or account creation that want bot protection without running their own infrastructure. It is a natural fit for operators who already use Google Cloud, and for larger platforms that need to protect accounts against takeover and credential stuffing.

It is less suited for operators who do not want to ask for consent for a security service, for organisations that must not embed US providers, and for sites with very high volumes that want to avoid usage costs.

How reCAPTCHA Compares

The best-known US alternative is Cloudflare Turnstile. It works without a visible puzzle, can be used without Cloudflare’s CDN, and according to Cloudflare processes only the data strictly necessary for this security function. hCaptcha is another well-known option.

euroboxx lists six European alternatives: ALTCHA (Germany), Friendly Captcha (Germany), Trustcaptcha (Germany), Private Captcha (EU), Swetrix CAPTCHA (Ukraine), and mCaptcha. Most of them emphasise data protection and checks without image puzzles, while reCAPTCHA offers more in areas such as account protection, risk scores, and mobile SDKs. Whether a specific CAPTCHA needs consent depends on the tool and how it is used, not on its origin alone.

Résumé

reCAPTCHA is a mature bot protection service with a free entry tier and features that go well beyond forms. The 2026 switch to a data processor role is a real change, but it has not settled the consent question that European authorities and courts answered strictly before. If you work with Google Cloud and need account protection, reCAPTCHA is a strong option. If you want a lean CAPTCHA from a European provider, the alternatives are worth a look.

All alternatives at a glance

Missing a European provider? Submit your software

ALTCHA
🇩🇪 Allemagne
Vérification des bots sans puzzles visuels
Cybersécurité et confidentialitéFreemiumOpen source
Site web
Friendly Captcha
🇩🇪 Allemagne
Protection contre les bots sans puzzles manuels
Cybersécurité et confidentialitéFreemium
Site web
mCaptcha
International
CAPTCHA open source fondé sur la preuve de travail
Cybersécurité et confidentialitéGratuitOpen source
Site web
Vérifications en arrière-plan pour formulaires et API
Cybersécurité et confidentialitéPayant
Site web
Swetrix CAPTCHA
🇺🇦 Ukraine
CAPTCHA avec calculs en arrière-plan
Cybersécurité et confidentialitéFreemiumOpen source
Site web
Trustcaptcha
🇩🇪 Allemagne
Vérification des bots sans puzzles visuels
Cybersécurité et confidentialitéPayant
Site web

Résultats : 6 au total

Trustcaptcha

🇩🇪
Allemagne

Trustcaptcha fait partie de la plateforme TrustComponent. Il combine des calculs de preuve de travail en arrière-plan, un score de risque et des règles réglables.

Swetrix CAPTCHA

🇺🇦
Ukraine

Swetrix CAPTCHA est un outil open source de protection contre les bots, inclus dans les offres Swetrix Analytics. Des calculs en arrière-plan remplacent les puzzles visuels.

Private Captcha

L'UE

Private Captcha protège formulaires et API avec des tâches cryptographiques résolues en arrière-plan par le navigateur. Leur difficulté s’adapte au trafic.

mCaptcha

International

mCaptcha est un système CAPTCHA open source fondé sur la preuve de travail. Au lieu de demander aux visiteurs de reconnaître des images, le navigateur effectue un calcul puis reçoit un jeton que le serveur du site doit vérifier.

Friendly Captcha logo

Friendly Captcha

🇩🇪
Allemagne

Friendly Captcha vérifie les navigateurs par des calculs en arrière-plan, sans puzzles visuels pour les visiteurs. Le service s’intègre aux sites, formulaires et applications.

ALTCHA logo

ALTCHA

🇩🇪
Allemagne

ALTCHA : des contrôles CAPTCHA sans puzzles visuels pour tes formulaires…

FAQ reCAPTCHA

reCAPTCHA est un système de sécurité qui protège les sites web des robots en analysant le comportement des utilisateurs, en vérifiant les interactions humaines et en bloquant les soumissions automatisées de spam.
De nombreux sites web préfèrent des solutions offrant des protections plus strictes de la vie privée, l'absence de suivi comportemental, un traitement des données basé sur l'UE ou une expérience utilisateur plus simple sans image intrusive ni cases à cocher.
Oui. Les outils de sécurité modernes combinent l'analyse des risques, la vérification des appareils, la validation côté serveur et des méthodes non intrusives pour bloquer les robots avec une grande précision, souvent sans interrompre l'expérience de l'utilisateur.
La plupart des systèmes axés sur la protection de la vie privée évitent le suivi intersite, l'empreinte digitale ou le profilage comportemental. Certains utilisent des contrôles JavaScript légers ou une logique côté serveur au lieu de défis pour l'utilisateur.
Parmi les facteurs clés, citons le respect de la vie privée, l'expérience utilisateur, la précision de la détection, les options d'intégration, les fonctions de validation côté serveur et la compatibilité avec votre système de gestion de contenu (CMS) ou de formulaires.
Découvre les logiciels européens